Reflection Questions on AI

[Team Two – Alumni Team]


Note:

Collaborative reflection on inquiry questions associated with AI and authorship helped launch, and continues to inform, our work. We invite visitors to this website and readers of our writings about our project (here and elsewhere) to adopt or adapt these questions for additional community-building reflection as a generatively human response to AI’s cultural force.

Six Reflection Questions on AI, Authorship, and the Teaching of Writing:


  1. In what ways do you currently use AI tools in your own writing, and what motivates these choices?
  2. How do you (hope to/plan to) incorporate AI into your teaching practices (e.g., assignment design, feedback, preparation), and what purposes does it serve for you?
  3. What concerns or challenges do you associate with students’ use of AI in your current or future courses, and what factors shape these concerns?
  4. How has the emergence of AI prompted you to rethink your teaching philosophy or learning goals? – (in that vein, and specifically, how to even define our AI usage policies in the classroom?)
  5. How is AI affecting your approach to assessing student writing? What questions about how to evaluate writing–the student’s, AIs, and hybrids–are you addressing directly in your instruction for/with your students? For example, how does student voice and agency enter into AI-linked pedagogy for you?
  6. [Response optional: This question was added toward the end of Team One’s initial composing process. Not all members responded.] What are ways that human-focused, collaborative knowledge making and writing, operating on a smaller interpersonal scale than AI’s LLMs, can still operate in our culture? What approaches and structures of experience would foster such work? What kinds of contributions could it make?

Team Two Responses

Whereas Team One members wrote their responses to our prompts into a Google Doc working asynchronously, Team Two held a Zoom meeting, which was recorded and transcribed. That transcript is below. Beneath the transcript, you’ll find preliminary analysis of these reflections.

Reflection Collaborators

Many elements in our current website language withhold specific information now so as to facilitate anonymized peer review of the essay. In the future, we hope to provide citation information so that website visitors will be able to find the essay in a published article form.

Tyler

Team Two, Midwest state university

Sarah

Team One, Discussion Facilitator

Jackie

Team Two, Southwest state university

Josh

Team Two, Midwest state university

Tristan

Team One, Discussion Facilitator

Transcript of Team Two Reflection Responses:


Download or scroll through the PDF below to read the full transcript of Team Two’s Reflections in response to our guiding reflection questions.

In reading the transcript of Team Two’s reflections, you will note that each participant in the conversation has had an opportunity to edit text from the initial Zoom conversation. Changes they made to their individual reflections are indicated by colored font and/or highlighted text.


Our Analysis-Building Process:


After Tristan and Sarah created the preliminary analysis of Team Two’s conversation that appears in our essay, four additional members from our two collaborating project groups re-read the transcript as well. Working independently, each of these contributors (Amanda, Gunja, Josh, and Tyler) identified themes that stood out to them when reading the transcript. They also flagged particular quotes that led to their recognizing those themes. Our essay provides a chart naming and gathering this set of themes and the co-author who highlighted each.

With the added space provided by this website, here we provide fuller descriptions of all the themes emerging from that process, along with the related quotations from the transcript that prompted respective contributors’ interpretive choices. In addition, we offer brief commentary below based on reading these analytical submissions in conversation with each other. In doing so, we continue our process of layering (and expanding) our micro-community’s interpersonal language archive.

Please use the buttons below to jump to each team member’s Reading and Key Themes.

Tyler‘s Reading and Key Themes


Theme #1: Utility

One potential utility of AI is for bureaucratic/administrative documents commonly circulated among writing program administrators.

Josh: “It all came down to a simple lack of time and emotional energy when you’re running around managing composition programs all day”Jackie: “I’ve started using it [for grant reports], and it’s probably given me a week of my life back”

Theme #2: Connection

It’s not necessarily the case that using AI is bad for students, but there are concerns that over-reliance on these technologies can weaken our social connections.

Tyler: “the value [a writing teacher has] is that she’s a human being. It’s the connection. It’s sitting down with another human being, and engaging in the process of collaborating and talking together and seeing a human being as a person, as another thing in front of you. That’s what makes writing such a personal, vulnerable thing. It’s because you’re co-creating meaning with other people.”Jackie, “I’m not opposed to students using [AI]…but I want them to also feel like they’re not atrophying. Or that we’ve lost sight of this grander purpose that writing serves, which is, in my opinion, social connection…to feel a part of something bigger than ourselves, that kind of collective effervescence”Josh, “The physical artifact feels more significant to me now than ever, some tangible proof that a human being stood in that space and had that thought.”

Theme #3: Humanity

There is a larger concern about the relationship between large language models and consciousness, and how we tend to connect writing to our fundamental sense of what it means to be human.

Josh: “think it would be a mistake to dismiss the anxieties and concerns over this technology as par for the course. I don’t think the Word Processor made us question what it is to be human or if being human matters anymore.”Tyler: “what really worries me [is] the kind of impact it’s going to have on a generation of students and their capacity for learning.”Jackie: “I think my primary concern will always be with this idea that students are losing the ability to do something that makes them feel well.”

Josh‘s Reading and Key Themes


Theme #1: Human Agency

Writing is valuable because it is a human act of judgment, responsibility, and presence. AI may assist human thinking, but it should never replace the fundamentally human work of authorship.

Josh: “The physical artifact feels more significant to me now than ever, some tangible proof that a human being stood in that space and had that thought.”Tyler: “”The value [a writing teacher has] is that she’s a human being. It’s the connection. It’s sitting down with another human being, engaging in the process of collaborating and talking together and seeing a human being as a person… That’s what makes writing such a personal, vulnerable thing.”Jackie: “I’m not opposed to students using AI… but I want them to also feel like they’re not atrophying. Or that we’ve not lost sight of this grander purpose that writing serves… to feel a part of something bigger than ourselves.”

Theme #2: Intentional Stewardship

Writing program administrators have a responsibility to incorporate AI deliberately rather than reactively. Administrative efficiency matters only when it creates more time for deeply human educational work.

Josh: “I started using it to write syllabi about a year ago.”Tyler: “What really worries me is the kind of impact it’s going to have on a generation of students and their capacity for learning.”Jackie: “I’ve started using it [for grant reports], and it’s probably given me a week of my life back.”

Theme #3: Protecting Human Possibility

The central educational challenge is not preserving old technologies or resisting new ones. It is preserving the uniquely human capacities that education exists to cultivate.

Josh: “I think it would be a mistake to dismiss the anxieties and concerns over this technology as par for the course. I don’t think the word processor made us question what it is to be human or if being human matters anymore.”Tyler: “What really worries me is the kind of impact it’s going to have on a generation of students and their capacity for learning.”Jackie: “I think my primary concern will always be with this idea that students are losing the ability to do something that makes them feel well.”

Amanda‘s Reading and Key Themes


Theme #1: Needs VS Capabilities

We tend to draw the boundaries of positive/helpful AI use based on whether AI can do the task well (and efficiently) when compared to humans, distracting from questions about human needs. For English educators, these include questions about the reasons people write, especially the “non-practical” ones.

Jackie: “Writing is a vehicle… for self-expression that’s really important to individual wellbeing…. So I think my primary concern will always be with this idea that students are losing the ability to do something […] that makes them feel well.”

Theme #2: Collaboration

In an increasingly technological university space, we need to consider how to build spaces where students are encouraged to collaborate with other humans, knowing the motivation and approach to working with humans differs from the same with AI.

Josh: “How do you insist on creating genuine human connections with your students under these conditions [of rising AI usage]?”Tyler: The value she has is that she’s a human being. It’s the connection. It’s sitting down with another human being, and engaging in the process of collaborating and talking together and seeing a human being as a person, as another thing in front of you. That’s what makes writing such a personal, vulnerable thing. It’s because you’re co-creating meaning with other people. And so any way that we can do that in the classroom is going to be helpful.

Gunja‘s Reading and Key Themes


Theme #1: Tensions, Impositions, Resistance

Ongoing tensions are operating between political enforcement and passive consumption of AI and the need for sites of active resistance.

Tyler: “On one side, we’re critical of AI, and teaching students how to use it ‘ethically’ or encouraging them not to use it at all, while at the same time, our university is implementing this institution-wide LLM that’s supposed to revolutionize teaching and learning. And the whiplash between the macro-institutional level versus the kinds of conversations at the ground level are colliding, and I think our students are in the same predicament that we are. We feel like unwitting participants in this massive game that tech bros are playing. I think if we look at them as victims, it might change our orientation a bit. I don’t know, I feel bad for them, and I feel like they’re victims in the same way that we are.”

Theme #2: Potential Power of Whimsy as Resistance

Using whimsy in the classroom could act as a strategic interruption to overreliance upon LLMs, since it sparks fun, joy, and spontaneous conversations, therefore focusing more on the process as opposed to the refined finished product.

Jackie: “I bought Taylor Swift Lover-Era heart sunglasses for my students, and we used those to talk about our lenses we adopt when engaging in critical thinking. And we’re doing, like, mindful breathing and walks, and I’ve gotten into doodling lately[…] I have students draw, and Play-Doh[…] So it’s changed what I do, and it’s gotten weirder[…]. To try to get students to pay attention and also feel like their work and their authentic voices are to be celebrated, and the work, the work of writing should be fun, right?”

Connecting the Analyses:

Sarah and Jackie (with input from additional team members)


Reading across these thematic analyses (from Amanda, Gunja, Josh, and Tyler) of Team Two’s reflections transcript, we can spotlight a number of conversational connections as well as ideas for future inquiry on AI and authorship. 

Connections arise both through placing these entries in dialogue with each other and through noting overlaps with the initial set of reflections from Team One. For instance, we (Sarah and Jackie) are struck by all four of these analysts’ underscoring–if sometimes using different wording–questions about AI’s (potential) encroachment on human wellbeing and paths to learning. Relatedly, and more optimistically, these four readers’ reengagement with Team Two’s conversation surfaced some possibilities for countering this threat in our teaching. One way, they noted, might be through teaching that reasserts human capabilities, such as whimsy and fun (from Jackie’s reflective comments) or, more broadly, by capitalizing on human interaction (Tyler’s affirmation of a human writing teacher as “sitting down with another human being, and engaging in the process of collaborating and talking together and seeing a human being as a person”).

Another recurring theme across these four analyses involves the need to recognize pressures from various institutions and stakeholders, whose investments in AI make it impossible to ignore and, for students, mean that ethical concerns we raise (whether posed as questions or refusal) are subjecting them to mixed messages about (in)appropriate AI authorship. 

Further, in several of the analyses we see acknowledgement that in some situations, for some tasks, AI may be useful to us–including in sites of writing, such as administrative tasks. Even so, adopting for specific tasks does not mean ignoring the challenges AI and its LLMs bring to our and our students’ humanities. After all, several comments in the transcripts–highlighted by virtue of our four interpreters’ flagging them as themes–bring together willingness to use/experiment with AI alongside the concerns about our and our students’ humanity noted above. 

Implicit in these exploratory interpretive materials and explicitly identified in follow-up conversations, are more/new questions for future inquiry related to these reflections and our project more broadly:

  • What might we gain by putting the reflections from Team Two in dialogue with those from Team One, as well as, potentially, future respondents to our reflective prompts?
    • For instance, might what seems to be a greater willingness among Team Two members to adopt AI in their own writing be linked to professional responsibilities they already have but which most Team One members are not yet facing?
    • By extension, are students more “able” to resist AI than faculty with administrative burdens that include tasks they don’t find humanizing?
  • What role do our namings play in how we think about AI and authorship?
    • We noted some differences in how our analysts named themes they saw. What nuances are embedded in those distinctions?
    • How might working together around some thematic terms contribute to shared understandings? 
  • How do the terms we adopt or create to “speak” about AI culture shape our thinking and authorial practices?
    • Thinking further about naming and terminology: as we have been writing here and throughout our project collaborations, we have often noted the rhetorical and affective impact of terms that name aspects of AI culture in action. How do the terms we create and/or adopt shape our thinking, in human terms, about these cultural shifts? For instance, does the AI term itself oversell LLMs (they are “just” language models)?
    • But is the opposite true? The names we give technologies draw boundaries around the possible futures we imagine for them.
    • Rather than asking, “What if ChatGPT is intelligent?” should we be asking, “What possible spaces close when we insist on framing them in terms of our own intelligence?” If they are something we are not, then what might they become when we let them be? 
  • While continuing to address our concerns about AI’s encroachment on our humanities, how can we also tap into the possible opportunity it brings to cultivate awareness of, and expanded (even new?) abilities in literacies that humans have and AI doesn’t?
    • These might include fun, interpersonal collaboration, heightened skills for critical contemplation about our humanities, and….?